A few weeks ago I decided that I desperately needed new work shoes pronto. I didnt have to time to go to Lenox mall so I ran to Cumberland, or as we all prefer to call it, SCUMberland Mall. I figured that Macys would have a similar selection regardless of the mall and I would start there. When I did not find anything that I even came close to liking I went through a few other stores just to check. I happened to find a pair of shoes at Also that I REALLY liked. I was on a mission for black closed toe high heel shoes. I found these.

I actually liked them so much I also bought them in Nude. They were $75 a pair but I knew I would wear them. Anyway, I bought them on Monday. Tuesday I wore the nude pair to work with a really cute skirt and sweater outfit. I was mostly sitting in meetings all day but when I walked to the bathroom at one point I could feel something poking my foot. I figured it was a stone but when I took the shoe off and looked at it I could see what looked like a nail or something sticking up through the insole. Luckily I had the black pair in my car still, so I changed and called Aldo to tell them.
By the time I had a minute to run to the mall to exchange them it was Friday. I showed the store manager the shoe, explained that I had bought them Monday and worn them for a half day Tuesday. She immediately told me that because I had worn the shoe she could not return or exchange it for me, per their policy. After trying to reason with the woman (named Tata....but whatever) for over 20 minutes I was just about in tears. She told me that there was nothing she could do and at one point even insinuated that perhaps I had put the nail in it myself. She actually attenpted to "fix" the shoe by using the tip of a pair of scissors to push the nail back down into the sole! When I was not satisfied with that (call me crazy), she suggested I put a gel insole into the shoe!!
I tend to think I am a pretty reasonable person. I can understand why a shoe store has a policy against exchanging worn shoes. BUT, its not like Id had them for a month and decided I didnt like the color. These were clearly defective shoes. Finally Tata offered to send them out for repair and try to get an exception made to the policy if they could not be returned. I was so exhasperated at that point that I couldnt wait to leave the store, so I agreed. She promised the shoe would be sent out on Monday and back by Weds. When I hadnt heard back by Friday I called the store to check back, only to find out that the shoe had never even been sent out for repair. The girl I spoke with said she would call me back that afternoon to tell me what was going on. If you can imagine this, I never got a phone call.
On Monday I decided to just go into the store. I figured that if worse came to worse I would take my defective shoe back and take it to another store in hopes of finding a reasonable and dependable staff memeber there. When I arrived and explained who I was, etc the lady at the counter told me that Tata had actually been fired. The new manager agreed to exchange the shoes for me without question. THANK GOD, right!? As it turns out they didnt have my size/color in the store but they offered to order them for me and have them delivered to my house for free. That sounded reasonable to me so I gave the girl my information and left the store, happy that this mess had been resolved.
Well, of course this ordeal just got worse. Why would I think this had been resolved!? I just checked my order at aldoshoes.com and realized that the lady at the store has now sent me a second pair of BLACK shoes!!! Arrrrghhhhhhhh.
I called the customer service line to confirm this and ask that they change my order, but that would be too easy. Since the order was paid in full the only option is to cancel it and wait 5 days for a refund. Since I dont trust anyone even affiliated with Aldo at this point I am letting them just ship me the shoes. I will then take them to the Lenox mall store I guess. I will say that I have been WAY to patient with the entire situation. I should have just returned both pairs and demanded my money back a long time ago. But alas, I like the shoes...
Am I crazy or is this the most unreasonable and ridiculous customer service story you have ever heard? So needless to say I will never ever buy another pair of shoes from Aldo and I would recommend that no one else does either. Unless of course you are a glutton for punishment.





